Oct. 2, 2011
PROFESSIONAL DIVISION
Winner: Carri Frank, self-employed, Harrisburg
» Pumpkin ginger w/ cinnamon buttercream
Runner Up: Tarsha Eaddy, Mother Boyd’s Kitchen, Red Lion
» Italian cream
AMATEUR DIVISION
Winner: Nikki Fanus
» Spiced apple
Runner Up: Teri Jakob
» Crème brûlée w/ salted honey butter caramel
Professional Division Contestants (in alphabetical order)
| Name | Company | City | Cupcake Flavor |
| Jenny Bates | self | Mechanicsburg | Sweet potato w/ brown sugar frosting and toasted marshmallow |
| Kimberly Cale | self | Carlisle | Carrot |
| Sara Cuthbert | self | Elizabethtown | Caramel apple cider |
| Lynn DeAngelis | Lucky Ducks Cakes | Lancaster | Boston cream |
| Marie Elena Howe | Cupcakes by M.E. | Lewisberry | Chocolate-covered caramel |
| Kellie Knipe | self | Camp Hill | Pineapple upside-down |
| Sarah Koveleski | Just Cupcakes | York | The Elvis |
| Jena Lawrence | Simply Sweet Boutique | Harrisburg | Pumpkin pie w/ pumpkin spice buttercream |
| Donna Lussier | La Petite Patisserie | Willow Street | Strawberrries and cream |
| Natalie Mahaney | Bsciotti’s Custom Bakery | Mechanicsburg | Coconut carrot w/ lemon cream cheese |
| Katie Matusiak | Katie Cakes Cakery | Cleona | Cannoli cake |
| Kate Reed | self | Ephrata | Almond joy |
| Wendi Saposnek | SweeTreats | Mechanicsburg | Red velvet |
| Barbara Sciotti | Bsciotti’s Custom Bakery | Mechanicsburg | Chocolate mocha fudge |
| Alisha Smith | D’Lish Cake Co. | Shippensburg | Apple w/ caramel cream |
| Jennifer Strayer | Simply Sweet Cupcakery | York | Chocolate mint dandy |
| Becky Waganer | The Cupcakery & More | Glen Rock | Orange creamsicle |
| Tracy Weinstock | Custom Cupcakes by Tracy Weinstock | Lancaster | Patriotic cupcake |
Amateur Division Contestants (in alphabetical order)
| Name | City | Cupcake Flavor |
| Andrea Black | Harrisburg | Chocolate w/ orange buttercream |
| Sydney Burkhart | Mechanicsburg | Pumpkin roll |
| Rebecca Bush | Harrisburg | Banana split |
| Matthew Caylor | Harrisburg | Geek cakes (Mt. Dew-infused, caffeinated) |
| Mary Beth Davidson | Hellam | Chocolate peanut butter |
| Gabi Dougherty | York | Lemon blueberry |
| Nikki Fanus | Ephrata | Spiced apple |
| Kelsey Gangwish | Harrisburg | Tailgate cupcakes (chocolate) |
| Letitia Gensbigler | Mechanicsburg | After dinner cupcakes (chocolate mint) |
| Cynthia Graeff | Harrisburg | Vegan carrot cake w/ faux cream cheese |
| Kathy Hoffman | Halifax | Chocolate w/ peanut butter ganache |
| Teri Jakob | New Cumberland | Crème brûlée w/ salted honey butter caramel |
| Kim Jede | Mechanicsburg | Cotton candy |
| Ashley Keefe | Palmyra | Devil’s food sundae |
| Bailey Kleinberg | Harrisburg | Banana chocolate chip w/ Nutella buttercream |
| Amanda Messick | Mount Gretna | Snickerdoodle |
| Amy Morris | Lititz | Carmel mocha java |
| Marie Mortimer | Middletown | Orange spice |
| Jennifer Oswald | Mechanicsburg | Bananas Foster |
| Leslie Reese | Hershey | Chocolate peanut butter pretzel delight |
| Mallory Royer | Hershey | Chocolate pumpkin |
| Amanda Shafer | Harrisburg | Rootbeer float |
| Sara Thompson | Harrisburg | Vanilla salted caramel |
| Christine Tobias | Middletown | Lemon w/ blueberry curd filling and lemon basil buttercream |
| Jason Valdez | Mechanicsburg | Strawberry lime mojito |
| Michael Velez | Harrisburg | Pumpkin chai |
| Gina Walters | Middletown | Banoffee |
